Sacrificial Steel Stools V Needling
The temporary support system for creation of an opening by use of sacrificial steel stools is inherently safest when it comes to risk of damaging the building. This is because the load-path always follows the same line to the foundations as for the permanent structure. With a needling system the load is transferred to a secondary system often with temporary foundations and back into the wall once the frame has been installed. This can lead to considerable movement, and in particularly sensitive buildings i.e. Listed Buildings and buildings having multi-ownership this can be unacceptable.
Speed of Construction
Generally installation of a beam or frame by use of sacrificial stools is quicker than an equivalent needling system. The works can be carried out entirely by one contractor without the need to worry about temporary foundations, making good of floor and ceilings, or making good of needle positions. For concrete beams and frames there is no need for fire proofing.
Cost of Sacrificial Stools V Needling
At the out-set the cost of needling appears to cost less than an equivalent system using sacrificial stools. However once making good, fire cladding, temporary foundations, disruption to other works is taken into account then the cost is at least the same and often less for sacrificial stools. Where this system often wins out is speed of construction and the fact that only one trade is involved.
Applications:
• Shop Fitting
• Building Refurbishment
• Opening up a building for more space
• Change of use for a building.
Gaining Access to the Location of the Beam/Frame
For large frames in buildings having restricted access a heavy steel beam can present difficulties for gaining access. There are safety concerns in terms of manoeuvrability/lifting. Reinforced concrete can be pumped and the reinforcing steel manhandled into the site. When a frame is required to be installed at ceiling level and within the depth of the floor then needling is sometimes precluded as an option especially when access to the upper and lower floors is prevented.
Simple Beam, Beam and Columns, Complete Frame or Entire Floor.
Especially by use of RC work the complete floor of an entire building can be framed out to make open space. For example a labrynth of small rooms within an old masonry building can be opened up for use as a public area such as a bar, office or assembly area. Reinforced concrete has inherent stiffness and is particularly useful when it is necessary to carry the moment around the joists.
Predeflection
Any of the above systems whether it be a steel or RC frame can be preloaded by hydraulic jacking before creating the opening.
|